For the ‘quality management representative’ (so last century), there should be no surprises in an exit meeting about the findings from an audit. Why? Because your lead auditor should have kept you informed throughout the audit process. Why? Because once a finding is raised, regardless of classification, the auditor should seek and obtain agreement from the auditee and/or the management representative that the finding has been accurately identified with supporting objective evidence.
The only time there might ever be a surprise finding is when the audit team collaborate their findings in an audit team meeting just before the exit meeting. They may find an adverse trend requiring the finding to be escalated. If this happens, the lead auditor should advise the management representative immediately so that the situation can be agreed to or mitigated by providing additional evidence.
Why would they want to do any of the above? Well it is their charter as third party auditors to find conformance and, in my mind, to mitigate the severity of findings if they can. This does not mean you get to argue the point, every point or every interpretation. It means that once brought to your attention, you can find mutual agreement on the finding, the evidence and the classification.
How would you know that? Your certification body should have published criteria on this so that you can respond accordingly. Or you can become aware of these requirements through preparation, business community contacts, or even full lead auditor training from your chosen certification provider, which will equip you for the dreaded exit meeting and the result. Of course, you could rely on your fractional management systems coordinator, who helped structure the management system and prepared you for the audit.
All of this then leads us to the final result and how it was communicated to the management team at the end of the audit, in the exit meeting. There are no rules here. Hopefully, your lead auditor will ask the management representative how much detail you would like in the final commentary on the audit and the results. That said, all certification providers do this a little differently. All have to meet the minimum JASANZ requirements, which stipulate that there is a process/policy for exit meetings and what should be said. But the actual delivery is subject to an agreed format, delivery, duration, and findings details, etc. The shortest exit meeting I have experienced is around 10 minutes. The longest is over 90 minutes. The same message was delivered, but the auditor's meeting management will determine how granularly the details of the result are explored.
In my experience, when acting as a lead auditor, I announce the result of whether a recommendation for certification to be granted, continued or not granted immediately after the initial welcome and appreciation to the company and management team. So those attending know within 2 minutes of the meeting starting. After that, the length and breadth of the delivery of the details will follow. Just remember, the exit meeting is not the time to challenge findings and argue points of law. Accept the result and get on with what you need to celebrate or fix.
Of course, if you have retained one of our team to get you to that exit meeting, you can feel comfortable in the fact that after 34 years of exit meetings, the words ‘congratulations, you will be recommended for certification’ are spoken 100% of the time.